1558
I. Siokou-Frangou et al.: Mediterranean plankton
Table 3. Site, sampling data depths and variables measured and source of the studies considered in this review. S: surface, INT: integrated
data, chl a: chl a concentration, BA: bacterial abundance, VA: Viral abundance, BP: bacterial production, VBR: ratio of viral abundance
respect to bacterial abundance, VBM: viral mortality on bacteria, n: number of data.
Location
Date
Depth
n
Variables
References
(m)
WMS
NW MS
June 1995
5–200 (S, INT)
42
chl a, BA, VA, VBM, VBR
Guixa-Boixereu et al. (1999b)
NW MS
June 1999
5–200 (S, INT)
10
BA, VA, VBM, VBR
Weinbauer et al. (2003)
Alboran Sea
October and November 2004
1–200 (S, INT)
6
BA, VA, BP, VBR
Magagnini et al. (2007)
W MS
October and November 2004
1–200 (S, INT)
16
BA, VA, BP, VBR
Magagnini et al. (2007)
Tyrrhenian Sea
October and November 2004
1–200 (S, INT)
11
BA, VA, BP, VBR
Magagnini et al. (2007)
Straits of Sicily
October and November 2004
1–200 (S, INT)
15
BA, VA, BP, VBR
Magagnini et al. (2007)
EMS
Adriatic Sea
May 91–November 1992
0,5 (S)
chl a, BA, VA, VBR
Weinbauer et al. (2003)
January–February 2001
1–1200 (S)
6
BA, VA, BP, VBR
Corinaldesi et al. (2003)
April–May 2003
(S)
BA, VA, BP, VBR
Bongiorni et al. (2005)
Ionian Sea
October and November 2004
1–200 (S, INT)
19
BA, VA, BP, VBR
Magagnini et al. (2007)
4.1
Viruses
The net effect of viruses with regard to the pelagic food web
is the transformation of particulate organic matter (the host)
into more viruses, and returning biomass into the pools of
dissolved and colloidal organic matter – “the viral shunt”.
Studies on viruses in the open MS are scarce, even less than
in other marine regions. To date, most Mediterranean work
has addressed viral control on bacterial biomass rather than
the characterization of the viral community. The studies have
revealed viral abundance in the surface waters which vary
between 0.08±0.01×10
7
and 1.6±4.8×10
7
viruses ml
−
1
,
while lower values occur in deeper waters (Fig. 12, Table 3).
In the MS as in other marine areas, viral abundance in-
creases from oligotrophic to more eutrophic waters. Existing
data (Table 3) also suggest that, while viral abundance cor-
relates with chl a concentration (n=46, r=0.409, p<0.05),
a tighter relationship exists between viral and bacterial abun-
dance (n=46, r=0.549, p<0.01) implying that bacteria are
more probable virus hosts than phytoplankton cells. Con-
sidering the data set for bacterial abundances and bacterial
production (BP), we found that viral abundance were re-
lated to both variables (n=24, r=0.520, p<0.05 and n=24,
r=
0.421, p<0.05, respectively). The low correlation be-
tween viral and bacterial abundance partly reflects the fact
that the virus to bacteria abundance ratio (VBR) in the upper
200 m layer of the MS varies between 5 and 50 (Fig. 12).
The wide range of this ratio suggests that viruses may be
associated to different types of host organisms, and/or that
viral concentrations vary over short times, causing different
sampling events to reflect different phases of infection and
release from host cells.
Comparing the WMS and EMS, viral and bacterial abun-
dance appears to be more tightly coupled in the west than
in the east (Fig. 13 and Table 4). However, these trends
Fig. 12. Average surface viral and bacterial abundance from the dif-
ferent Mediterranean sites (A), average integrated values (1–200 m),
that were normalized in each case dividing them by the maximal
considered depth (B). Bars are SD of the mean. NWM: NW-MS,
ALB: Alboran, WM: WMS, THY: Tyrrhenian, SICH: Straits of
Sicily, ADR: Adriatic, ION: Ionian (B).
have to be taken cautiously, because the number of samples
from the EMS is relatively limited, and differences between
slopes are not statistically significant (t -student, t
value
=
2.3;
p=
0.17). Viral infection accounts for less than 20% of bac-
terial mortality in the Catalan Sea thus being definitely less
important than mortality due to grazing by protists (Guixa-
Boixereu et al., 1999a,b). However, virus-induced mortal-
ity can occasionally prevail over grazing by heterotrophic
Biogeosciences, 7, 1543–1586, 2010
www.biogeosciences.net/7/1543/2010/
I. Siokou-Frangou et al.: Mediterranean plankton
1559
Fig. 13. Relationship between bacterial and viral abundance (log
transformed), taken at depths between 5 and 200 m, for WMS and
EMS waters.
nanoflagellates, for example at higher bacterial abundance in
coastal waters (Weinbauer and Peduzzi, 1994; Boras et al.,
2009). In a gradient from eutrophic to oligotrophic waters
in the Adriatic Sea, viral production was higher in eutrophic
areas and viral decay rates were not balanced by viral pro-
duction rates over short time scales (Bongiorni et al., 2005).
Alonso et al. (2002) characterized 26 bacteriophages of
the viral community found in the Alboran Sea. Most of them
belonged to two of the three tailed families of the order Cau-
dovirales; phages were grouped in 11 classes on the basis
of protein patterns and their size ranged between 30 nm and
>
100 nm. Different morphotypes of bacteria hosted viruses
of different sizes. Thus, virus between 30 and 60 nm mainly
infected rods (74%) and spirillae bacteria (100%), while
viruses between 60 to 110 nm were mostly found inside cocci
(65.5%).
4.2
Bacteria
The first study in the open MS examined the ultra-
oligotrophic waters of the Levantine Sea (Zohary and
Robarts, 1992) revealing that bacterial abundance, at
3×10
8
cells l
−
1
, was clustered around the lower threshold of
the world ocean value (Cho and Azam, 1990). In the MS,
while bacterial concentations are quite stable and bacterial
production is low (Table 5) there are important variability
aspects to consider: (i) the west-east gradient of decreasing
bacterial production (Christaki et al., 2001; Van Wambeke
et al., 2000, 2002), and (ii) the enhanced metabolic activities
and production related to specific hydrologic discontinuities,
such as currents, eddies and frontal areas (Fern´andez et al.,
1994; Moran et al., 2001; Van Wambeke et al., 2004; Zer-
voudaki et al., 2007). Interestingly, the slopes of log-log lin-
ear regressions for bacterial biomass and bacterial production
obtained for the WMS and EMS (Fig. 14a) are not signif-
icantly different (t
value
= −
0.22; p=0.85) with both slopes
being smaller than 0.4, thus suggesting top-down control on
bacteria (Billen et al., 1990; Ducklow, 1992).
Table 4. Number (n) of data used to find out the relationships be-
tween different variables in the Western Mediterranean (WMS) and
the Eastern Mediterranean (EMS). BA: bacterial abundance; BP:
Bacterial production; VA: viral abundance; PP: primary production;
HNF: heterotrophic nanoflagellates abundance; Cil: ciliate abun-
dances; Chl: chl a concentration.
Variables
WMS
EMS
Source
(n)
(n)
BA-VA
42
0
Guixa-Boixereu et al. (1999a)
38
19
Magagnini et al. (2007)
0
6
Weinbauer et al. (2003),
Corinaldesi et al. (2003)
Bongiorni et al. (2005)
10
0
Weinbauer et al. (2003)
BA-BP
0
174
Christaki et al. (2003)
8
0
Vaqu´e et al. (2001)
0
13
Robarts et al. (1996)
13
18
Van Wambeke et al. (2002)
26
50
Christaki et al. (2001)
0
91
Van Wambeke et al. (2000)
BP-PP
48
29
Turley et al. (2000)
22
24
Christaki et al. (2002)
26
0
Pedr´os-Ali´o et al. (1999)
HNF-BA
12
0
Christaki et al. (1996),
Christaki et al. (1998)
36
45
Christaki et al. (2001)
8
0
Vaqu´e et al. (2001)
0
48
Siokou-Frangou et al. (2002)
Cil-Chl
20
42
Pitta et al. (2001)
8
0
Vaqu´e et al. (2001)
79
0
Dolan and Marras´e (1995)
Following the general pattern of increasing oligotrophy
eastward, bacterial production is several times lower in
the eastern than in the western basin (Turley et al., 2000;
Van Wambeke et al., 2000, 2002). However, the relation-
ship between bacterial production and primary production is
quite similar in the EMS and WMS. Expanding on the data
set from Turley et al. (2000) (Table 4), plots of log BP and log
primary production (PP) for the WMS and the EMS display
similar positive slopes (t
value
= −
0.22; p=0.87) (Fig. 14b).
This significant positive relationship between BP and PP sug-
gests that primary production is an important source of DOC
fuelling bacterioplankton.
A crucial factor that might limit bacterial production in the
MS is the availability of inorganic nutrients, especially phos-
phorus. Nutrient control on bacterial production, as well as
on bacterial adaptations to cope with the oligotrophy of the
open MS, has been experimentally approached in a number
of studies. During a Lagrangian experiment, phosphate ad-
dition to ultra-oligotrophic surface waters of the Levantine
Sea caused an unexpected ecosystem response: a decline in
www.biogeosciences.net/7/1543/2010/
Biogeosciences, 7, 1543–1586, 2010