39
Stemming girls’ chronic poverty: Catalysing development change by building just social institutions
Box 15: Existing evidence on gender differences in children’s time use
Gender-disaggregated data on children’s time use are still in a fledgling state globally. Based on fragmented evidence, however, a
picture of girls’ relative time poverty emerges. Evidence from Mexico, for instance, shows that girls spend 175 percent more time on
household tasks than boys (Brunnich et al., 2005). Similarly an Understanding Children’s Work (UCW) study in 2006 found that, in
El Salvador, three times as many girls as boys undertook 28 hours or more of household chores per week; in Costa Rica, Guatemala,
Nicaragua and Panama, at least twice as many girls as boys did so. In the case of economic activities, more boys than girls were found
to be engaged in such work, although the measure used was one hour of economic activity for every 14 hours of household chores,
suggesting that economic activity in the region is considerably more valued than household labour.
In Africa, several studies have focused
on the different opportunity costs
of investing in girls and boys within
households as an explanation for
gender disparities and son preference.
If opportunity costs are measured
according to the lost labour to a
household as a result of sending
children to school, households often
lose more by sending girls to school. In
Tanzania, for example, the opportunity
cost of sending 13- to 15-year-old girls
to school is significantly higher than
that of sending 13- to 15-year-old boys,
for whom the cost is 25 hours of work
per week compared with 37 hours
per week for girls (World Bank, 1999).
Further studies have confirmed that
this effect is consistent across all ages
(Mason and Khandher, in Ritchie et
al., 2004). In Uganda, girls work 21.6
hours per week compared with 18.8
hours per week for boys; in Guinea,
rural girls work 22.9 hours compared
with boys’ 17.4 hours; and a cross-
country study of Kenya and South
Africa showed that girls spend more
time on household work compared
with boys, representing a greater
opportunity cost to households if girls
engage in non-domestic work activities
(in Ritchie et al., 2004).
Pörtner (2009) shows that age and
gender often intersect in important
ways with regard to shaping time
use. Older girls (14 to 16 years) in
the Philippines have more demands
on their time than boys and younger
girls in terms of both housework and
market activities.
Percentage of children in household chores for at least 28 hours per week, 7 to 14 years
Source: UCW (2006)
Time spent per day collecting water and firewood in minutes, boys and
girls aged 6 to 14 for Benin and Madagascar and 7 to 14 for Ghana
Source: Charmes (2006, in Blackden and Wodon, 2006)
Time use in hours per week of children in the Philippines, by age
Source: Pörtner (2009)
Fetching Water
Collecting Firewood
Boys
Girls
Boys
Girls
Benin (1998)
19
46
5
12
Madagascar (2001)
16
31
19
6
Ghana (1998)
38
41
29
30
Time use in hours per week of children in the Philippines, by age
School
Market
House
Boys
Girls
Boys
Girls
Boys
Girls
7-9 years old
36.9
33.12
9.98
5.5
6.86
7.95
10-13
years old
39.25
41.08
11.89
17.85
8.1
11.8
14-16 years old
38.08
40.47
25.36
27.53
7.64
18.84
Overall
38.3
38.82
19.17
23.04
7.74
13.99
19
46
5
12
16
31
19
6
38
41
29
30
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
Boys
Girls
Boys
Girls
Fetching Water
Collecting Firewood
Mi
nut
es
spe
nt
pe
r w
ee
k
Benin (1998)
Madagascar (2001)
Ghana (1998)
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Boys
Girls
Boys
Girls
Boys
Girls
School
Market
House
Ho
ur
s p
er
w
eek
7-9 years old
10-13 years old
14-16 years old
Overall
Percentage of children in household chores for at least 28 hours per week 7 to 14 years
Boy
Girl
Columbia
3
5
Costa Rica
1
2
Dominican Republic
10
11
Ecuador
1
1
El Salvador
1
2
Guatemala
6
19
Honduras
8
15
Nicaragua
7
14
Panama
0
1
Time spent per day collecting water and firewood in minutes, boys and girls aged 6 to 14 for Benin and Madagascar and 7 to 14 for Ghana
3
1
10
1
1
6
8
7
0
5
2
11
1
2
19
15
14
1
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
Per
cen
ta
ge o
f C
hi
ld
ren
Boy
Girl
Fetching Water
Collecting Firewood
Boys
Girls
Boys
Girls
Benin (1998)
19
46
5
12
Madagascar (2001)
16
31
19
6
Ghana (1998)
38
41
29
30
Time use in hours per week of children in the Philippines, by age
School
Market
House
Boys
Girls
Boys
Girls
Boys
Girls
7-9 years old
36.9
33.12
9.98
5.5
6.86
7.95
10-13 years old
39.25
41.08
11.89
17.85
8.1
11.8
14-16 years old
38.08
40.47
25.36
27.53
7.64
18.84
Overall
38.3
38.82
19.17
23.04
7.74
13.99
19
46
5
12
16
31
19
6
38
41
29
30
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
Boys
Girls
Boys
Girls
Fetching Water
Collecting Firewood
Mi
nut
es
spe
nt
pe
r w
ee
k
Benin (1998)
Madagascar (2001)
Ghana (1998)
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Boys
Girls
Boys
Girls
Boys
Girls
School
Market
House
Ho
ur
s p
er
w
eek
7-9 years old
10-13 years old
14-16 years old
Overall