What are driver diagrams and logic models and what is the difference between them? What are they?

What are driver diagrams and logic models and what is the difference between them?


1. What are they?
Driver diagrams and logic models are tools to help planning. They both provide a “theory of change”.

Driver diagrams are a type of structured logic chart with three or more levels. Examples Driver diagram 1 Driver Diagram 2 Driver diagrams include:

a goal or vision

the high-level factors that you need to influence in order to achieve this goal (called ‘primary drivers’)

specific projects and activities that would act upon these factors

Logic models are a type of structured diagram which connects Outcomes with Activities and specifies Reach (or target groups) for those activities. NHS Heath Scotland has created logic models along with other tools which are underpinned by evidence on a range of topics. The collective term for these resources is outcomes frameworks . Logic models include:

Long-term outcomes

Intermediate outcomes

Short-term outcomes

Reach (or target) group

Activities

2. When can they be used?
Both logic models and driver diagrams can:

• 
  help a group to explore the factors that they believe need to be addressed in order to achieve a specific overall goal or outcome
  
• 
  show how the factors are connected
  
• 
  act as a communication tool for explaining a change strategy
  
• 
  provide the basis for a measurement framework
  

3. How do you use them?

Driver diagrams - The steps in the process of creating a driver diagram are:

1. Gather together a group of experts on the subject matter

2. Brainstorm to identify the things which need to be improved to achieve the goal (presumably the goal has been specified previously)
3. Cluster the ideas to see if groups represent a common driver
4. Expand the groups (or single ideas) to see if new drivers come to mind
5. Logically link together the groups into a driver diagram format
6. Work backwards from project ideas if that helps
Logic models -The steps in the process of creating a logic model are:

1. Set up a group of experts

2. Identify outcomes based on the available evidence
3. Group outcomes into common themes
4. Refer to the relevant outcomes framework to ensure all appropriate outcomes have been considered, including unintended outcomes
5. Put outcomes in a hierarchy
6. Identify reach (or target group) and activities which will achieve the outcomes. Including reach will help you consider inequality issues.
7. Measuring outcomes and reflect on draft model


4. What is the difference between them?

1. Driver diagrams work back from the project, whereas logic models work backwards from the outcome. Consequently, logic models may be better at helping planners priorities based on outcomes

2. Logic models which have been created by NHS Health Scotland are underpinned by evidence, driver diagrams are informed by expert opinion
3. Logic models include “Reach” and are useful in identifying inequalities issues which should be considered when planning effective activities which will achieve desired outcomes
4. While there is evidence that using logic models improves planning, we have not identified any evidence that using driver diagrams improves planning.

5. Links to more information on driver diagrams and logic models

Driver diagrams: http://www.institute.nhs.uk/quality_and_service_improvement_tools/quality_and_service_improvement_tools/driver_diagrams.html

http://www.institute.nhs.uk/images/documents/Quality_and_value/Driver%20Diagram%20further%20information.pdf

Logic models:

http://www.healthscotland.com/OFHI/
http://www.evaluationsupportscotland.org.uk/article.asp?id=165